Home › New York › Long Island › Benner's Farm

Benner's Farm

East Setauket, New York · Long Island

Benner's Farm is a fifteen-acre family homestead offering pumpkin picking, haunted hayrides, seasonal festivals, educational programs, camps and private tours.

What's here

  • PumpkinsPick your ownSep, Oct
  • HayridesSep, Oct
  • StrawberriesJun
  • Festivals & events
  • Farm market

Season

JJanFFebMMarAAprMMayJJun (open)JJulAAugSSep (open)OOct (open)NNovDDec

Maple sugaring in February, strawberry celebrations in June, and haunted hayrides and pumpkin picking in fall. Summer and school-break camps are offered.

Hours

Office staff available 11–2 most days; visitor hours not stated. Call to book private tours and classes.

Good to know

  • Organic
  • School groups
  • Parties & private events

We took these details from the farm's own website (bennersfarm.com). Hours, prices and crops change with the weather, so check with the farm before you go. Something wrong?

Nearby farms

White Post Farm

Melville, NY · Updated for 2026

White Post Farms offers a petting zoo, giraffe feeding, bird aviaries, playgrounds and a dinosaur exhibit. Seasonal attractions include pumpkin picking, hayrides, Easter activities and a fall festival.

  • 🎃 Pumpkins
  • 🚜 Hayrides
  • 🐐 Farm animals
  • 🧺 Farm markets
  • 🎪 Festivals

May's Farm

Wading River, NY

May’s Farm offers June sweet pea picking, October pumpkin picking, hayrides and a corn maze, plus cut-your-own Christmas trees. Its farm stand sells fresh produce, plants, jams and jellies.

  • 🎃 Pumpkins
  • 🎄 Christmas trees
  • 🌽 Corn mazes
  • 💐 Flowers
  • 🚜 Hayrides

Waterdrinker Family Farm & Garden

Manorville, NY · Updated for 2026

Waterdrinker offers u-pick Christmas trees, seasonal festivals, and a Winter Wonderland with lights, skating, barnyard animals, and play activities. Its website invites vendors for 2026 festivals.

  • 🎄 Christmas trees
  • 🌻 Sunflowers
  • 💐 Flowers
  • 🥧 Cider & bakery
  • 🧺 Farm markets